Newt Gingrich Lost the Arizona Republican Debate

3
Newt, Gingrich, debate, aggression, energy, oil, calm, daughters, Romney

Newt Gingrich Lost the Arizona Republican Debate

Share on Facebook

Looking at some of the statistics, it's not obvious why Gingrich is considered less important than Rick Santorum. He has more endorsements than Rick Santorum, and more total primary-goers have voted for him. Heck he even has the most twitter followers!

Of course though, we know that he's been badly beaten in recent contests. He has won fewer states and has fewer delegates to his credit than both Santorum and Romney. His nemesis throughout the primary has been Mitt Romney, who he has accused of attacking him with ads and misrepresenting his record. The two have sparred in past debates and many people expected that this debate would show Gingrich at his most pugnacious and aggressive. Michele Bachmann's former campaign adviser put it simply, “he's got one shot.”

Interestingly, Gingrich did not opt for extreme aggression in his last stand. Prior to the debate, Gingrich promised that he would try to focus on big issues like his energy plan. He also pledged to “stay out of the kind of negativity that unfortunately has characterized way too much of this race.” He also said he would try to focus on his energy plan.

He only kind of succeeded at this master plan, and even then, it was because no one baited him, which would have been enough to drive him into the discussion with more passion.

Gingrich was able to intercede in some squabbling between Romney and Santorum and did so in a grandiose fashion, and on earmarks Gingrich took the side of Romney and said that “he supported the governor.” He also talked broadly about the competence and modernity of the government, trying to craft a grand vision. 

He was also able to talk about his energy plan, but he didn't have too much opportunity to bring it up, as auto-bailouts and earmarks were the most contentious early discussions. He could have brought up the relationship between energy and the auto industry, but he didn't.

At points though, he got angry. On the issue of auto bailouts, he criticized Romney heavily, and said that writing checks to the auto industry was wrong and that it was was a violation of bankruptcy law at the expense of bondholders.

For the most part though, Gingrich was quiet, simply because his views weren't very important for this debate and his moment of influence had passed. There was no blow up in the debate between Romney and Gingrich. Is it possible that they got over their bad blood? 

 

Photo CreditGage Skidmore


Share on Facebook
3

Sign up to join the discussion

Reply to this article
view profile

Jordan Wolf

My training is partially in philosophy and I'm interested in democratic theory, but more practically, I like thinking about media sophistica...

Most Mic'd Response

weekly-winner-headshot-fpo

Ben Poole

Fair synopsis of the debate as to this topic. And yes, Newt and Mitt are party men with Mitt being the favorite of the insiders. Santorum is also but for the religious conservative. Newt will hang in to Super Tuesday and thereafter not be critical of the front runner if its Mitt unless he is neck and neck. Santorum didn't have a good night but hung in. Romney did better. Most of the airtime went to those two. Newt was sidelined about like Paul but not near as bad as in any other debate. It won't get a lot of airtime play because there was no entertainment tonight. It actually was a debate somewhat fairly moderated.

Watch the PolicyMic Video Join PolicyMic

The Discussion

Jordan, I found this pretty funny. Your summary said, "Newt Gingrich was largely successful in staying calm..."

That's pretty much sums up how people judge Newt Gingrich.

  • Mic this! 0
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!

Fair synopsis of the debate as to this topic. And yes, Newt and Mitt are party men with Mitt being the favorite of the insiders. Santorum is also but for the religious conservative. Newt will hang in to Super Tuesday and thereafter not be critical of the front runner if its Mitt unless he is neck and neck.

Santorum didn't have a good night but hung in. Romney did better. Most of the airtime went to those two. Newt was sidelined about like Paul but not near as bad as in any other debate. It won't get a lot of airtime play because there was no entertainment tonight. It actually was a debate somewhat fairly moderated.

  • Mic this! 1
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!

1 Replies

  • David Gray 3 months ago I agree with you Ben. No one seemed...

I agree with you Ben. No one seemed to have a bad night, yet no one seemed to have a great night. I thought Romney and Gingrich had the better. When it comes to Gingrich though, he did not have a breakout debate performance like he did in South Carolina. Then again, no one had a breakout performance.

It actually was a somewhat dull debate. I guess that is to be expected being the 20th one. Everyone is honed and on message. As much as I hate it, maybe debates are no longer a good platform from this point on (I was really mad when they pulled out of the GA debate because I planned on attending it).

  • Mic this! 0
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!
Join PolicyMic

What is PolicyMic?