Is a Disrespectful Tweet Free Speech? Not For Kansas Governor Sam Brownback

11

Gov. Brownback.

Kansas governor Sam Brownback should have remembered that there's no such thing as bad publicity before he demanded a high school senior write him a letter of apology after tweeting negatively about him.

Eighteen-year-old Emma Sullivan tweeted “Just made mean comments at gov. brownback and told him he sucked, in person #heblowsalot,” after hearing Brownback speak in Topeka, Kansas. Brownback deemed the tweet “disrespectful” and ordered her school to force her to write an apology letter. Sullivan decided not to write the letter and her story gained media coverage, after which Brownback claimed he over-reacted and that she didn't need to write an apology.

Though the wording may not have been the most sophisticated, her tweet was an expression of free speech and she had no need to apologize. Brownback’s initial reaction only works to discredits Brownback and brings attention to Sullivan instead. Brownback's decision to cut arts funding for public schools was her main reason for writing the disparaging tweet. Sullivan has a platform, and now publicity and an outlet to further her agenda. Last week, the teenager had about 60 followers, since the incident she attained over 14,000 followers, about four times more than Brownback’s Twitter following. Brownback underestimated how quickly news spreads via social networks, which effectively ruined his image since his attempts to punish Sullivan for voicing her opinon resonates with proponents of free speech.

This generation has been characterized by political apathy. If politicians want more people, especially young adults, to be interested in politics, incidents like these are simply unacceptable. If anything, Brownback should have applauded her for speaking her mind. If Sullivan wrote an editorial or drew a political cartoon for example, Brownback would probably not have reacted the way he did, much less noticed. Though she did not detail exactly why she thinks he “blows a lot” and she probably could have come up with a more sophisticated way to argue her point, she's still making a highly relevant political analysis. She didn't expect it to be so important, but ultimately this action shows that her opinion doesn't matter and that an 18-year-olds way of expressing themselves doesn't matter. This incident could potentially discourage other young adults from getting involved in politics.

Social media is a powerful tool to connect constituents to candidates. There are ways people can utilize twitter to bolster their campaigns, but as evidenced by Brownback's misstep, it can also be a reflection of a problem with politician's conception of free speech. People like Brownback argue that they want to protect the Constitution; they really mean they want to protect it when it's convenient for their political agenda. First Amendment rights mean nothing to politicians if it doesn't make them look good.

Photo Credit: VictoryNH

11

Sign up to join the discussion

Reply to this article
view profile

Nina C. Trumbo

University of Chicago ‘11, Political Science. Chicago via D.C. Social science researcher, engaged in community issues....

Most Mic'd Response

weekly-winner-headshot-fpo

Jon Awbrey

Pompous Twit v. Punchy Tweet

Watch the PolicyMic Video Join PolicyMic

The Discussion

The whole point of tweeting is giving a person the ability to express their opinion in quickly to a broad audience, similar to the whole point of free speech. If Gov. Brownback can't handle a teen's comments about his own shortcomings, he has no right to demand the student to apologize for anything. At least he (or his people) realized that eventually

  • Mic this! 2
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!

that's probably the best hashtag I've ever seen.

  • Mic this! 1
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!

Does his office really have nothing else to do that they have TIME to scour the internet to find ONE random tweet? The people of that state should be outraged that they tax dollars are paying his office for that. As for Sullivan, this experience will make a great college essay.

  • Mic this! 2
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!

As I have remarked - here and in other fora - fascist is as fascist does.

Governor Brownback and his ilk, all elected in 2010, misread their election as a repudiation of everything "Barack Obama." They have fallen into arrogance and overreaching for power; allowing ALEC to write their rights-denying legislation in all areas: stripping unions, limiting women's rights and healthcare access, abusing LGBT rights, shutting down basic Constitutional rights such as free speech and the right to assemble, etc. What the elections in 2010 were REALLY about was the economic situation...people were frightened and upset and ready to "throw the bastards out" like they always do in midterms. The Republicans will pay for their stupidity next November.

  • Mic this! 4
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!

Ms. Trumbo, I totally agree with your post. The senator should have responded in a constructive way to the child, but chose to take advantage of his position and slam the the tweet. I would say the young lady should understand that criticism is best made in a constructive manner and with respect. Also, she should have consulted with her English teacher about her choice of vocabulary. This type of harsh rhetoric by all Americans is emblematic of our society today.

  • Mic this! 3
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!

1 Replies

  • Nina C. Trumbo 5 months ago Thank you, Mr. Bommarito. I think y...

Thank you, Mr. Bommarito. I think you have a great point about constructive criticism. If Sullivan wrote wrote a thought out critical essay on her political stance, Gov. Brownback may not have even noticed or cared, and she would have expressed herself in a more appropriate manner. It's so easy to devolve into petty partisan arguments, but we would be much better served if people spent time to craft a critical discourse. Even if an agreement can't be reached, both sides' opinions are heard and ideas can be considered instead of wasting time.

  • Mic this! 0
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!
  • No longer with us
  • 5 months ago

This account has been disabled.

  • Mic this! 4
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!

1 Replies

  • Susan Kraykowski 5 months ago LOL! If I could give more than 1 mi...

LOL! If I could give more than 1 mic for that; I would! WHERE is my cookie badge?!?

  • Mic this! 2
  • Reply
char limit
Please wait before posting another comment to this article. Thanks!
Join PolicyMic

What is PolicyMic?